If you were a kid in the 80s and 90s, you surely remember “Magic Shell”, a popular dessert topping known for its ability to harden quickly when poured onto cold surfaces. In fact, Magic Shell can still be purchased in-store and online today.
However, as a now grown-up girl-at-heart, who likes to manage both her carb count and pocketbook, I like to make my own no-sugar like magic shell chocolate sauce using just two ingredients – sugar free chocolate chips and coconut oil! THAT’S IT!
To make a generous, 2-serving batch just add 1-ounce sugar free chocolate chips (about 3 tbsp) to a small microwave-safe bowl and add 1 teaspoon of coconut oil – it’s fine if still in solid form, it all melts together! Next, microwave for about 35-45 seconds until melting, then stir together until glossy and smooth. If you want a bigger batch, simply use the same 1 oz chocolate to 1 tsp coconut oil ratio – you may need to microwave a little longer to accommodate the larger volume.
.So, now that the chocolate sauce that hardens is done, it will work its “magic” by solidifying on contact with cold items – the coconut oil helps make it easy to drizzle, but then reverts back to its solid state after cooling! You can speed up the hardening process further by sticking your drizzled, dunked and dipped items into the fridge for a minute or two afterward.
FUN WAYS TO USE SUGAR-FREE “LIKE MAGIC” SHELL TOPPING
Frozen Treats: Pour over ice cream and frozen yogurt. Even dunk popsicles into it!
Cold Desserts: Yogurt parfaits, trifles, frozen pies, cheesecakes and more.
Drink Rims: Add to the rim of a cold cocktail glass before filling – what a fun and delicious surprise!
Decorative Designs: Write a name or “draw” a design on a chilled plate or serving dish before placing ice cream or desserts on them.
Dipped & Drizzled Treats: Dip cookies, pretzels, marshmallows, or other snacks into hardening chocolate sauce quick chocolate coating. Try drizzling on popcorn that’s cooled and then tossing on coarse sea salt – -so good!
Fruit: Dip fresh fruits like strawberries, bananas, and apple slices into the sugar-free chocolate topping or drizzle across a bowl or tray full of fruit.
TIPS FOR MAKING & STORING SUGAR-FREE HARDENING CHOCOLATE SAUCE
No water. Don’t add any water to this recipe to thin it out — that’s going to mess it up. In fact, ensure that the bowl you are using to melt chocolate chips in is completely dry and free of moisture.
Choosing Chocolate Chips: You can use any chocolate chip that works for your dietary eating pattern – sugar-free or dairy-free or traditional style made with sugar. You can also choose another flavor of chip such as white chocolate, butterscotch, peanut butter, and such.
Oil Substitutions: NO! Do not substitute coconut oil for another oil – it will not harden back up in the same way and sauce will remain runny. Also, do NOT use coconut oil that has been “fractionated”, a processing step that keeps it in a liquid state at room temperature. Only use regular coconut oil that will appear solid at room temperature (under 78 degrees).
Application: Simply spoon the sugar-free magic shell onto its final destination or use a small drizzle bottle. I personally like to use a mini mason jar (2-oz), because I can also use that jar to melt the chocolate – so less mess!
Storage: Do not store leftovers in the fridge. Instead, cover tightly and keep on counter or pantry, until needed – it really doesn’t go bad (or, I’ve always gobbled mine up before it has – I’m sure it would take months). If it’s a colder day, you may need to pop it in the microwave for 5-10 seconds to make more pourable.
I like to use this sugar-free magic shell sauce on my protein cheesecakes, it adds a lot of fun, flavor and flair — and I don’t have to worry about excess sugar.
Get the recipe for Boston Cream Pie Protein Cheesecake.
Note: This post contains affiliate links and I may earn a small commission on purchases — which I use to offset operating expense for The Fit Fork. Thank you!
I love using this to spruce up frozen fruit for a somewhat healthy summer dessert. Most recently we covered a tray of frozen blueberries with this delicious sauce. Loved the chocolately crunch.
I’m so excited to try this! I love white chocolate, and I’m always looking for ways to incorporate it into my diet. This is going to be perfect for baked goods.
This was so helpful! I would love to try incorporating this into cheesecakes. For sure, this will be my next go-to dessert!
Thank you for sharing.These tips were very helpful and everything turned out perfectly specially the cheesecake.