I’ve always had a thing for creamy tomato soup. It’s comforting and tastes like a hug – and my kids say it double as a dip for grilled cheese or breadsticks.
Since I love ordering creamy tomato soup in a restaurant, I thought – why not try to make a copy-cat Panera tomato soup or copy-cat La Madeline tomato basil soup at home with convenience products?
The recipe tastes like it’s been simmering all day under the mindful watch of a grandmother but, in reality, it’s been thrown together in mere minutes with healthier convenience products.
Tomato-Based Pasta Sauce: The beauty here is a jarred sauce has an almost eternal pantry shelf life, saves hours of preparation time over homemade and thus adds an instant, rich, complex flavor to the soup. You can slightly switch up the flavor profiles of this tomato soup recipe depending on what variety (like garlic, spicy, etc.). I look for no-added-sugar options and am a fan of marinara and tomato pasta sauces from Primal Kitchens.
Prepared Broth: Use broth, chicken or vegetable (depending on your preferences) from a carton, jar, stock base or even reconstituted from a bouillon cube. For this semi-homemade recipe, I used the clean-label Chicken Bone Broth Culinary Concentrate from Zoup!! They also make the best-tasting vegan veggie broth I have ever tasted.
Petite-diced Tomatoes: Adding finely chopped tomatoes to give the semi-homemade tomato soup a little more texture is just a Jennifer thing. Traditional creamy tomato soups are . . .. well, smooth and creamy. So, if you don’t like chunks in your soup, then simple omit and add 6 ounces more pasta sauce.
Heavy Cream (or Coconut Cream): Cream makes everything better, right?! This recipe used “just enough” cream to tone down acid tomatoes and add a rich, full-bodied mouth feel while keeping the macros pretty balanced. If you are vegan or lactose-intolerant, the cream may be swapped out in an equal portion for full-fat coconut cream from a can – the unsweetened stuff. However, the soup flavor will change – but it’s still delicious!
Herbs and Spices: Ground black pepper please! Also, elevate your traditional or vegan creamy tomato soup with fresh herbs. Basil is oh-so-traditional, or go for parsley, thyme or sage. If you don’t have fresh, a freeze-dried herb from Litehouse is the next-best option.
Protein Boost: Sometimes I want soup on the side, sometimes I want main-dish soup. I have an easy mix-in when making a meal out of a simple soup that includes no major source of protein other than from a smattering from veggies and broth – unflavored collagen. Yes, simply mix in a one to two servings of an unflavored collagen and the protein grams jump up significantly! I use a beef-sourced collagen from Great Lakes Wellness (discount code: THEFITFORK10OFF), but you can find other options including marine-based.
Throw all these things in a pot, stir over medium-heat until warmed (don’t boil), and BOOM you have just made three generous servings of an amazing tomato soup.
This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a small commission from your purchases, but the price to you remains the same. Thank you for supporting The Fit Fork and the companies I endorse.
- 1 ½ cups tomato-based pasta sauce from jar or homemade
- 1 ½ cups vegetable or chicken broth
- ¾ cup petite-diced tomatoes from can
- ½ cup heavy cream or substitute coconut cream if non-dairy
- 1 tsp. ground black pepper
- 1 tbsp. finely chopped basil or parsley, thyme or another preferred herb
-
Add all ingredients to 2-quart pot. Heat over medium heat until warmed through. Do not bring to boil. Divide among three bowls and garnish with extra herbs or other toppings like cheese and/or croutons.
Makes approximately 36 ounces of soup.
Per 12-oz serving:
